When i wored thorogoods edgewood was where i found them. I have since switched to redwing and wont be going back. They have similarly soft leather that doesnt need to be broken in but last longer than the thorogoods did. They do cost more but their like wearing sneakers around. Was wearing these https://goo.gl/images/FrtNjd but have swapped to these because i kept getting holes on the toe. https://goo.gl/images/Eg9evm