Need an EDC light...

[spanky]

the g2 is getting on my nerves as far as the size.

currently trying to decide between SF E1E & Fenix P1D CE.

Opinions? I know the Fenix is significantly brighter but I'm a little concerned with longevity and warranty on the Fenix. Should that even be a concern?

P1D - http://www.fenixlight.com/flashlight/fenixp1d.htm
E1E - http://www.surefire.com/maxexp/main...nbr=6&prrfnbr=803&sesent=0,0&search_id=952790

 

[greg t]

I currently EDC a G2 as well. I ordered a Fenix P3D to T&E for replacing the G2. I don't really have much to add other than I was in the same boat (except for the size which isn't an issue for me) and chose to T&E the Fenix. Ultimately, price came down to being the deciding factor.

 

[spanky]

How's the size difference of the P3D as compared to the G2?

 

[Cajun_Chuck]

So weird! I stayed up until 4 this morning because I was in manic phase trying to decide on the SP E1E & Fenix TK11 for the same reason you.

I had decided that I was going to get the fenix but at the last minute, changed my mind because I told myself that I was impulse buying. The only things I could find about the Fenix flashlight on different forums and review posts w/ the fenix was as issue w/ O-rings & wiring/connecting at the butt/power on button. These reviews were on different models and old, but....it still made me hesitate until today so I could find more info on it.

I am with you Spanky...looking right now.

http://www.fenixtactical.com/fenix-gallery.html
Above is the link to the new TK11

 

[greg t]

How's the size difference of the P3D as compared to the G2?

Looking at the specs of each, the P3D is slightly smaller in diameter and about .5" shorter. My G2 is slightly larger in diameter at the tailcap since I have the Z49 clicker cap (I kept accidently activating the regular tailcap).

 

[Cajun_Chuck]

Is the strobe function on a tactical light worth the price of admission?

 

[SKYWLKR]

If you need it for life saving get the E1E

if you need a light to see where you plug in a cord get the fenix...

 

[greg t]

If you need it for life saving get the E1E

if you need a light to see where you plug in a cord get the fenix...

Care to expound upon that assertion?

E1E is rated at a max of 15 lumens with a runtime of 1.5 hours; P1D is rated at a max of 180 lumens for 1 hour on its highest setting and 95 lumens at 2.8 hours at its next lower setting.

Perhaps you're referring to durability. If so, any links to relevant threads would be greatly appreciated

 

[SKYWLKR]

I don't need threads..

I have owned over 20 Fenix lights and 12 Sure fires.

I have had 3 fenix's go back for repair work, no Sure fires...

I do love Fenix lights and I carry two every day. A AAA E1 and a L1D bored to fit a CR123...

But on my bed side is a surefire, in my glove box is a surefire, in my wifes purse is a stream light.

 

[Manimal]

How's the size difference of the P3D as compared to the G2?

Significantly smaller, its thinner & the lighting face is smaller as well...

I've dropped my P3D (while in its very handy sheath) numerous times...its gotten wet a couple times. No real torture from me, but the videos I saw online impressed me enough.

P3D is brighter than G2, it's got much whiter light, its very solid (I would have no problems using it to smash up someones face, quite sure that it would be sturdy enough.), and I am 100% impressed.

I've had the same batteries in it since I got it...a month or so ago, and I use the flashlight every single day, without exception, for anywhere from 5mins to 1hr+.

It's supposed to have about 3hrs of continuous use on Turbo...I've never had it on for 3 hours straight but I've -definitely- got more than 3 hours of use with it so far.

I've checked the brightness of these batteries vs new ones twice and have yet to see any noticeable difference in the light output. It's just as bright as the day I got it.

Yes, it is blinding. The strobe feature is great.

Mine have been flawless so far, and they will be my survival light as well as all around light.

Don't forget to use the 5% or 8% off coupons if you buy one online. I don't know of any bigger ones.

 

[jmcrawf1]

Significantly smaller, its thinner & the lighting face is smaller as well...

I've dropped my P3D (while in its very handy sheath) numerous times...its gotten wet a couple times. No real torture from me, but the videos I saw online impressed me enough.

P3D is brighter than G2, it's got much whiter light, its very solid (I would have no problems using it to smash up someones face, quite sure that it would be sturdy enough.), and I am 100% impressed.

I've had the same batteries in it since I got it...a month or so ago, and I use the flashlight every single day, without exception, for anywhere from 5mins to 1hr+.

It's supposed to have about 3hrs of continuous use on Turbo...I've never had it on for 3 hours straight but I've -definitely- got more than 3 hours of use with it so far.

I've checked the brightness of these batteries vs new ones twice and have yet to see any noticeable difference in the light output. It's just as bright as the day I got it.

Yes, it is blinding. The strobe feature is great.

Mine have been flawless so far, and they will be my survival light as well as all around light.

Don't forget to use the 5% or 8% off coupons if you buy one online. I don't know of any bigger ones.

what's this coupon you speak of?

 

[Manimal]

what's this coupon you speak of?

handy thread here...

Do a google search though, "Fenix Light Coupon"...some places offer free shipping, others offer other stuff...

Check that thread out for discount info & handly knowledge about the light.

 

[greg t]

I don't need threads..

I have owned over 20 Fenix lights and 12 Sure fires.

I have had 3 fenix's go back for repair work, no Sure fires...

I do love Fenix lights and I carry two every day. A AAA E1 and a L1D bored to fit a CR123...

But on my bed side is a surefire, in my glove box is a surefire, in my wifes purse is a stream light.

Thank you for further explaining! Wild ass assertions on an internet forum are truly worth less than the paper they're written on.

How was your customer service experience with the lights that had to go back for repair?

 

[SKYWLKR]

Customer returns are great, I go through my retailer.

Fenix-Store.com and suggest any one else to do the same...
that is where the discount is.

I have a personal %10 off and I got a 20 gift card from the owner a while back

 

[SKYWLKR]

McGizmo Aleph

Wow , I though I was the only freak that had a taste for ridiculously expensive lights...

Do you have a Gat light (have had a few) or any of the Arc's?

 

[spanky]

come to think of it, i think the e1l is the one i was looking at getting...

 

[spanky]

More via PM if you're interested.

.

Surely.

 

[SKYWLKR]

Gat light...

http://www.lumencraft.net/

 

[swagge1]

I like my Fenix. I don't carry a light or use one very often, but the limitied use I have had with it did impress me.

 

[topgunz1]

Led stinger on the belt, standard stinger in the car, g2 led in my seat organizer.

My car light is a brinkman maxfire, which is identical to a g2. Fiance has a g2 in her car.

I don't carry a light on my person in regular clothes