He is not as good as Rogers, Manning or Brady. Those are just current QB's. He is not close to the greatest QB in NFL history, nowhere close or even in the conversation. He is probably greatest Saints QB but that is it. Please don't take that to mean he is not a great QB, he is. Hyperbole of the greatest ever though does him a disservice. He is great just not at the greatest of all time level.
You sir, are wrong. I will give you Peyton but neither of the other two. Manning and Brees are by far the two best QB's in the game today. When it is all said and done Brees will be in the top 5 of all time with Marino, Elway, Manning and Favre. Rogers is not even in the conversation. And as far as I am concerned Brady gets close but doesnt get the nod even with 4 SB rings. People say Marino is one of the best to ever even touch a football and he never won a ring. Elway only has two and it took his entire career to get them. He almost retired without them.